Ask
25

Driftwood has turned the water the colour of weak tea - does this clear on its own, and does it matter to the plants?

Set up a ten gallon about three weeks ago with a piece of driftwood I soaked in a bucket for four days first. The water has gone a distinct yellow-brown. It is clear, not cloudy - I can see straight through, it just looks like tea.

Water parameters read normally and the plants are putting out new growth, so nothing seems obviously wrong. It is purely how it looks, and my partner has started calling it the swamp.

What I cannot find a straight answer on: does this stop by itself and roughly when, does it do anything to the plants, and if I want it gone is there a way that does not mean taking the wood out?

8 answers Share
Report

Answering anonymously, a moderator will review it first.

  • @carbon_swap_kaya · 3w ago · 2 replies

    If you want it gone without pulling the wood, activated carbon in the filter is the direct answer and it works fast: usually visibly clearer within a day or two.

    Things to know so it does not become a permanent fixture:

    It exhausts. Carbon binds until its surface is full and then it is just an expensive sponge. A month is a reasonable working life; after that it does nothing and people leave it in for a year believing it is still working.

    It is not selective. It pulls out tannins and it will also pull out liquid fertiliser and anything else dissolved. In a planted tank that matters: if you dose ferts, dose after the carbon has been in a while or you are partly feeding the filter. Some people run it only for a week to clear things up and then take it out, which for your situation is what I would do.

    Purigen is the alternative people reach for. It targets organics, it is more selective, and it can be regenerated rather than replaced. More expensive up front, cheaper over a couple of years, and it goes visibly brown so you can see when it is spent, which is genuinely useful.

    Either way, the wood keeps leaching underneath. You are treating the symptom, which is fine, but expect to repeat it a few times before the wood settles down.

    24
    Share
    Reply

    Answering anonymously, a moderator will review it first.

    Report
    • @purigen_user · 2w ago

      If you do want it clear, the resin option lasts much longer than carbon and can be regenerated with bleach solution rather than replaced. It also does not strip trace nutrients the way carbon can over long periods.

      Slower to act than carbon, so it is the one for maintenance rather than for a fix this weekend.

      18
      Share
      Reply

      Answering anonymously, a moderator will review it first.

      Report
  • @boil_it_first_bo · 3w ago · 2 replies

    It clears on its own, it is harmless, and four days of soaking was nowhere near enough - which is the useful part, because it tells you what to expect.

    What you are seeing is tannins leaching out of the wood. How long it runs depends on the type and size of the piece and how dense it is: a small piece of a light, porous wood might be done in a few weeks, a big dense piece can release visibly for months. Three weeks in is early.

    Things it actually does:

    • Lowers pH slightly and softens water a little. Usually small in a tank with normal water changes, and worth knowing rather than worrying about.
    • Absorbs a bit of light, which is the only real effect on plants. In a low-tech ten gallon this is marginal, but if you have anything light-hungry at the substrate it is a factor.
    • Nothing harmful. Fish from tannin-stained water actively prefer it.

    To speed it up: water changes are the honest answer, and they work in proportion to how much you change. Boiling the wood before it goes in pulls a lot out quickly and also helps it sink, soaking cold barely touches it, which is why your four days did so little. Repeated boils with fresh water each time is the fast route, but that means taking it out, which you said you would rather not do.

    30
    Share
    Reply

    Answering anonymously, a moderator will review it first.

    Report
    • @tannin_lover · 2w ago

      Boiling before it goes in does more in an hour than a week of cold soaking. The temperature is doing the work.

      10
      Share
      Reply

      Answering anonymously, a moderator will review it first.

      Report
  • @purigen_user · 2w ago

    Three weeks in is early. Mine ran tea-coloured for four months and then stopped on its own.

    7
    Share
    Reply

    Answering anonymously, a moderator will review it first.

    Report
  • @blackwater_on_purp · 3w ago · 3 replies

    The other option is to decide you like it, which is not a joke: a lot of people end up here.

    Tannin-stained water is what a great many tropical fish actually come from. Chocolate gurami, many tetras, licorice gourami, most soft-water species. The colour is a feature in a blackwater setup and people add leaf litter and cones specifically to get it, then complain when it fades.

    It also does two things worth having: it takes the glare off a tank that is slightly overlit, and it makes colours on the fish read much better than they do against bright clear water, particularly reds.

    On the plant question, since that is the practical worry: the plants that struggle in stained water are the demanding carpeting ones that already want a lot of light. Anubias, java fern, cryptocorynes, bucephalandra, most stems - completely fine, and crypts in particular tend to look better.

    Worth living with for a month before you buy anything. It fades gradually, and the version you have at week eight is usually much less dramatic than the swamp your partner is objecting to now.

    1
    Share
    Reply

    Answering anonymously, a moderator will review it first.

    Report
    • @tannin_lover · 3w ago · 2 replies

      Third option and I ended up here after fighting it for a year: tannins lower pH slightly and have mild antibacterial properties, so a tank full of them is closer to what a lot of soft-water fish evolved in.

      The tea colour is only a problem if you have decided it is. Shrimp and most tetras do visibly better in it.

      21
      Share
      Reply

      Answering anonymously, a moderator will review it first.

      Report
      • @blackwater_on_purp · 2w ago

        And once you stop fighting it, the wood stops being a problem and starts being a feature you paid for.

        13
        Share
        Reply

        Answering anonymously, a moderator will review it first.

        Report