AskMeAnything
Ask
Ask
28
@wipes_and_septic ·

Which of the septic tank rules are real and which are folklore? First house with a tank and I have been given contradictory lists.

Bought a place with a septic system in the spring. Between the previous owner, a neighbour and the internet I now have three different lists of things that will supposedly destroy it.

The ones I keep hearing: never use a garbage disposal, never flush anything labelled flushable, do not use bleach or antibacterial cleaners, do not put a water softener's discharge into it, and add a packet of bacteria every month.

Some of these sound plausible and some sound like something being sold. The bacteria packets in particular feel like the sort of thing that exists because people are anxious.

Which of these actually shorten the life of a system, and which are people repeating what they were told?

2 answers Share
Report

2 answers

BestTopNewOldControversial

Answering anonymously — a moderator will review it first.

  • @pumper_told_me · 6h ago
    @pumper_told_me ·

    The person to ask is whoever pumps your tank, because they see what is actually in there, and their list is much shorter than the internet's.

    Sorting yours:

    Wipes — completely real, and the worst thing on your list. "Flushable" means it clears the toilet, which is a much lower bar than breaking down. They do not disintegrate, they knit together into mats, and they are the number one cause of blocked pumps and filters. Nothing but toilet paper. This one is not folklore in any degree.

    Garbage disposal — real, and underrated. It adds a large volume of solids that break down slowly, so the sludge layer builds much faster. Systems with one need pumping considerably more often, and if you do not increase the frequency to match, solids carry over into the drainfield, which is the expensive failure.

    Bleach and cleaners — mostly overstated. Normal household use, in normal amounts, diluted by everything else going down the drain, is not going to sterilise a tank. Where it becomes real is volume: pouring a lot of anything strong down at once, or a hobby that puts solvents or paint into the drain.

    Softener discharge — genuinely debated, and there is more to it than a yes or no; someone will cover it below.

    Additive packets — no. This is the one being sold. A working tank is populated continuously by what enters it. There is no shortage to correct.

    30
    Share
    Reply

    Answering anonymously — a moderator will review it first.

    Report
  • @disposal_debate · 6h ago
    @disposal_debate ·

    I removed my disposal after a conversation with a septic contractor and I would do it again, but the honest version is that it is a maintenance-frequency question rather than a destruction question.

    A disposal does not break your system. It changes the arithmetic: more solids in, sludge layer rises faster, and the interval between pump-outs shortens — the figures people quote vary, but the direction is not disputed. If you keep the disposal and pump on a schedule that accounts for it, you are fine. The damage happens when people keep the disposal and the pumping schedule they inherited, which is the common case.

    What actually matters more than any single item on your list is pumping on time, and the reason is worth understanding. Solids that stay in the tank are harmless. Solids that carry over into the drainfield clog the soil, and a clogged drainfield is the failure that costs many thousands and cannot be undone by pumping. Everything on the folklore list is really a proxy for "do not overload the tank between pump-outs".

    So: composting or binning food waste, a sensible pumping interval for your tank size and household, and knowing where your tank and drainfield actually are. That is most of it.

    24
    Share
    Reply

    Answering anonymously — a moderator will review it first.

    Report