Ask
25
@banneton_swap ·

Proofing sourdough without a banneton, and the dusting rule that stops it sticking

A proofing basket is a nice object and it is not required. What it does is hold the shape and wick a little moisture from the surface. Several ordinary things do both.

Substitutes that work

  • A bowl lined with a clean tea towel. The standard answer and it works properly. A smooth cotton towel, generously floured. Avoid terry cloth, which the dough grips.
  • A colander with a cloth. Adds airflow, which helps the skin dry slightly, and gives you a ridged pattern if you like that.
  • A round cake tin or plastic container with a cloth. Whatever matches your loaf size.
  • A sieve, for smaller loaves, and it breathes well.

The dusting rule, which is the whole problem
Plain wheat flour absorbs water and turns to glue. Rice flour does not, because it has no gluten and does not hydrate the same way. A mix of about half rice flour and half wheat, dusted onto the cloth generously and rubbed into the weave, is the difference between a loaf that drops out and one you have to scrape.

Rub it in rather than sprinkling on top, so the flour is in the fabric rather than sitting on it.

The other half: keep it cold
Proofing in the fridge firms the surface and makes the whole thing far easier to handle, and it fits the schedule better. A cold loaf releases from a cloth much more willingly than a warm slack one.

What to skip: oiling the cloth, which makes it worse, and non-stick spray, which does nothing useful for dough.

8 answers Share
Report

Answering anonymously, a moderator will review it first.

  • @rice_flour_trick · 3w ago · 2 replies

    Rice flour is the answer and the technique matters as much as the flour. Rub it into the weave with your palm until the cloth looks slightly grey, rather than sprinkling a layer on top.

    A sprinkled layer gets pushed aside by the dough as it settles and then the dough touches fabric. Rubbed in, the flour stays in the gaps and there is no direct contact anywhere.

    Same principle if you use a real banneton, incidentally. Most sticking complaints about baskets are dusting complaints.

    24
    Share
    Reply

    Answering anonymously, a moderator will review it first.

    Report
    • @sticky_every_time · 2w ago

      Rubbing the rice flour into the weave rather than dusting on top is the entire technique and I ignored it for a year. Dusted flour sits on the surface and the dough pushes straight through it.

      Grey-looking cloth, then shake off the loose stuff. Nothing has stuck since.

      17
      Share
      Reply

      Answering anonymously, a moderator will review it first.

      Report
  • @colander_proof · 3w ago · 2 replies

    A plastic colander lined with a tea towel is the closest free substitute, because the holes let the surface dry the way a banneton's wicking does. The ridges even leave a pattern.

    Bowl works, colander works better, and everybody already owns one.

    20
    Share
    Reply

    Answering anonymously, a moderator will review it first.

    Report
    • @banneton_swap · 2w ago

      The airflow is the part people miss. A solid bowl holds moisture against the skin and that is where sticking starts.

      12
      Share
      Reply

      Answering anonymously, a moderator will review it first.

      Report
  • @sticky_every_time · 2w ago

    Terry towel is a trap that everybody falls into once, because it is the towel nearest the kitchen.

    7
    Share
    Reply

    Answering anonymously, a moderator will review it first.

    Report
  • @fridge_proof · 3w ago · 2 replies

    Cold proofing changes this from a problem to a non-problem, and it improves the bread as well.

    A loaf out of the fridge is firm, holds its shape when tipped out, and scores cleanly instead of dragging. A room temperature loaf at the same stage is slack and grabs everything.

    It also decouples the bake from the schedule, which is the actual reason most people switch and then never go back.

    1
    Share
    Reply

    Answering anonymously, a moderator will review it first.

    Report
    • @colander_proof · 2w ago

      Cold proofing makes every one of these substitutes work better. A cold loaf barely touches the cloth.

      11
      Share
      Reply

      Answering anonymously, a moderator will review it first.

      Report
  • @banneton_swap · 3w ago

    Avoid terry cloth. A smooth cotton tea towel releases; anything with a pile grips the dough no matter how much flour is on it, and that is most of the "my towel does not work" reports.

    1
    Share
    Reply

    Answering anonymously, a moderator will review it first.

    Report