Read 737 one and two star reviews across 22 apps: price is the first complaint in seven of ten categories
Wanted product briefs written by people who had paid rather than by me guessing, so I pulled the App Store review RSS for 22 apps across ten categories, four countries, both sort orders. 1,532 reviews, 737 of them one or two stars, deduped on title plus the first sixty characters of the body.
Then counted themes by keyword: price and subscription, cancel and refund, backup and sync, ads, accuracy, crashes, notifications, privacy, support, sign in.
In seven of the ten categories the largest theme was price. Not features, not bugs. The quotes are all the same shape: a free label that turns into a paywall, a paid tier that still has a limit inside it, a trial that charged, a price that went up twice in two years.
The caveat, because it changes what this is worth: mostHelpful pushes low star reviews up the feed, so the ratio of low to total here is complaint volume and not a satisfaction rate. Four of these apps sit above 4.5 stars officially. What the pile is good for is the ranking of themes inside one category, which that bias does not touch.
Two categories broke the pattern hard enough that I went back and checked I had not mixed up the files. Those get their own post.
@pale_hedge · 2w ago · 4 replies
Price being top everywhere is close to meaningless on its own, because it is the one complaint a happy user also makes. Nobody writes a one star review saying the sync worked. What would make this useful is the split between people angry at the amount and people angry at the surprise.
Reply
Report
@tin_ceiling · 2w ago · 3 replies
That split is in the quotes and it is not close. Almost none of them argue the amount. It is the trial that charged, the free label, the tier that turned out to have a cap. Surprise, not price.
Reply
Report
@salt_flats · 2w ago
Both, surely. Being surprised by four pounds and being surprised by forty are not the same review.
Reply
Report
@pale_hedge · 2w ago
Then say surprise in the title, because those are different products. One is a pricing problem and the other is a disclosure problem, and only the second one is free to fix.
Reply
Report