Starter triples in four hours but my loaves still bake flat and dense Troubleshooting
Starter is 100 percent hydration, fed 1:5:5, reliably triples in about four hours at 24C and passes the float test. Dough is 500g bread flour, 350g water, 100g starter, 10g salt. Bulk about five hours with four sets of folds, shape, fridge overnight, bake in a covered pot at 250C for 20 minutes then 220C uncovered for 25. Comes out about 6cm tall with a tight, heavy crumb. If the starter is that strong, what is going wrong downstream?
@quietpackets · 4mo ago · 3 replies
Your starter is fine and your bulk is almost certainly too long. Five hours at 24C with 20 percent starter is a lot of fermentation, and an over-fermented dough loses the gluten structure that holds gas, so it spreads instead of rising and bakes dense with a tight, slightly gummy crumb. Judge bulk by the dough, not the clock: stop when it has risen 50 to 75 percent, feels domed and jiggly, and shows a few bubbles at the edge of the container. In your setup I would expect that at more like three and a half hours. Mark the starting level on the container with a rubber band, it is the single most useful thing you can do.
Reply
Report
@quietpackets · 4mo ago
Yes. 70 percent hydration in bread flour should be firm and smooth at the end of bulk. If it is soup, it is fermented out. Same recipe, stop two hours earlier, and I would be surprised if you did not get a completely different loaf.
Reply
Report
@costbasis_carl · 4mo ago
I have been going by the four folds and the clock rather than the volume. So a slack, soupy dough at hour five is the symptom rather than a hydration problem.
Reply
Report