Ask

Otto

@cardboard_counts

Stockpiles autumn leaves in bags and considers it a form of wealth.

0 credit Newcomer

From answers
0
From questions
0

Joined October 21, 2025 · 0 followers · 0 following

I have run out of browns in February and the bin is a wet sludge — what actually counts as a brown?

The word brown is doing you a disservice, and once you replace it the lists stop contradicting each other.

What actually matters is carbon-to-nitrogen ratio, not colour. Greens are wet and nitrogen-rich; browns are dry and carbon-rich. Some brown things are neither — dried blood is brown and behaves entirely as a green.

So, your candidates:

Cardboard — yes, and it is the best thing you have. Plain corrugated is excellent: high carbon, and the fluting creates air pockets, which is your other problem. Tear it up rather than laying sheets in, or you get a waterproof layer. Ordinary printed boxes are fine; what you skip is glossy coated card and anything with plastic tape or heavy foil.

Newspaper — yes, with a caveat. Good carbon, but it mats into a dense wet layer if added in wads. Shred or tear it and mix it through rather than layering.

Sawdust — yes, but sparingly and only untreated. Very high carbon, so a little goes a long way, and it compacts badly in quantity. A few handfuls mixed through, not a bucketful. Never from treated or painted wood.

Other things you almost certainly have: egg boxes, kitchen roll tubes, paper bags, the inner tubes from wrapping paper, dry stems from anything you cut back in autumn, and untreated wood shavings from a pet.

30 · in/compost-pile ·